Clarification Around Contribuitor Roles Specification Of Each Role
I am writing because I need clarification on contributor roles, as I couldn’t find satisfactory answers in the existing documentation. I would like to know the specific definitions for each of the following “contributor” roles. Is there a specific page or guideline that details these functions?: For example, when crediting the peer reviewers who conducted the peer review and who are also editors of the journal, which role should I use? Furthermore, in a scientific article with a group of authors who all made an equivalent contribution, should all of them be designated as “first-author”? Or, after listing the “first-author,” should everyone else be listed as “additional-author” regardless of their collaboration?
How should I distinguish between them? Also, if a group of authors each performed a specific function, how do I distribute the “first-author” and “additional-author” roles? The CRediT taxonomy provides a standardized vocabulary for describing research contributions. Unlike traditional authorship lists that only show names, CRediT makes explicit what each person contributed to the research. Each of the 14 roles represents a distinct type of contribution to scholarly output. Contributors may be assigned one or more roles, and each role may be shared by multiple contributors.
This flexibility accurately represents how modern collaborative research actually works. Click on any role below to learn more about its definition, examples, and implementation guidance: Ideas; formulation or evolution of overarching research goals and aims. Management activities to annotate, scrub data, and maintain research data for initial and later use. These are the 14 roles included in the Contributor Role Taxonomy (CRediT). Alongside each definition we include examples of the types of activity and contribution that may fall under the definition; these are not exhaustive and are included for illustrative purposes only.
While CRediT is being used by publishers to capture information about the specific contributions of its authors, is is not designed to determine authorship; publishers adhere to strict guidelines around what qualifies as authorship. The CRediT roles can also be used to describe the contributions of individuals in contexts not related to article authorship. Conceptualization – Ideas, formulation or evolution of overarching research goals and aims. Data curation – Management activities to annotate (produce metadata), scrub data and maintain research data (including software code, where it is necessary for interpreting the data itself) for initial use and later re-use. Formal analysis – Application of statistical, mathematical, computational, or other formal techniques to analyze or synthesize study data. Correspondence: Tae-Il Kim (Editor-in-Chief).
Department of Periodontology, Seoul National University School of Dentistry, 101 Daehak-ro, Jongno-gu, Seoul 03080, Korea. periopf@snu.ac.kr, Tel: +82-2-2072-2642, Fax: +82-2-744-1349 Received 2017 Feb 7; Accepted 2017 Feb 7; Issue date 2017 Feb. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0). While an average of 2 authors per article used to be the norm in academic publishing until the 1960s, multi-authorship is now common in scientific articles. The emergence of this phenomenon seems natural considering the current system of incentives for researchers and the greater ease of collaboration thanks to advances in technology.
However, this has also led to some authorship-related issues, as discussed in the paper (https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.1997.03550070071041) published by Dr. Drummond Rennie and his colleagues in the Journal of the American Medical Association. In their article, they state that “the system of authorship has become inappropriate as the average number of authors of an article has increased; as the work of coauthors has become more specialized and... Credit and accountability cannot be assessed unless the contributions of those named as authors are disclosed to readers, so the system is flawed.” In order to address this problem, it is necessary to devise... Rather than merely listing all the names of the authors involved, it is necessary to have a defined set of terms describing various contributor roles and mechanisms, which would allow authors to take credit... The Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT) is a community-developed open-standard taxonomy of contributions that improves the understanding and communication of different kinds of contributor roles in research output.
Its taxonomy consists of the following 14 types of contribution to scholarly work: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Resources, Software, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing - original draft, and... Implementing this infrastructure in academic journals would eventually lead to the development of author-centric credit and impact tracking tools that would be able to fix the skewed authorship system that we have today. eXl+� ��U���*�H�0�K����[ ����:����Wcw�e�^a�Im.��ʻ��TT`�v�[�s�l��^FJ�%���[7{��S�-l���{A����'�"�<���i#xI���i弍8٫`��<�j6��,�ӵ�֬x��g�cg����sA���+���D^��v��l�Y���QмdH�;�ז �H\��S�f�o9;�N#���#i�|6���/�E{A��K��Y��yD�m���:�� A6�& v���ޅ����C��9:�k����Y�,�[<�fK�E��X�-��ݺ�����j�[���J��r�����d]���R���q����Z����a>�a�J���%�o�s��@��P}�j�0 ��r8g��h^9�Y���7C���N����Йjͱ�o�PZ~��jΏ�y>!U';�:��;�|�*X��Qu�_�·���_y�&�<����k�;( ����觡���)�7'���B=<.�#�p�6tD�7��ҹi�xKs��.Sw��5�>t ��+)!�������Q��I7��3 ��v�&])ݫYn�����T�d��,W�\����Ӑ�G�Ӑ8�#���]IkAr���ѓ@�j���l嶦l�_=��,�l[$6R�CC�!Ҟ;9Z��Ò4���� ���(稢Eꕠ�J3mH�t[}p� �z�f|JPo���H��{�������k[���m�}uz���t'������:}�F_�X��}3V��09�֔b�U�F��vc ��V���ǧ��d���heOm�o��-�Z�����:�V[=O_.�������HO��P>stream H�j`@ � endstream endobj 518 0 obj <>stream H��V}t����fv�$� �a�CB! ���l6|!!vÇ�لL��Q��p���!��P)`)m�E��� E=��r�ӣh)�PQ�U)����&D�=��3s����ǻo��$� #gV�x���/f��|� �^� {��&�z����~ق�6 ��1�W�ĺEk�N�'��xC]����^$�3������G�_d<�a٪�kʧ1>��O< ��ɯ�� ˂kE�m�2�����eu���?����u�s�b]���\ R.�v�p����= ��{�2����(�d�+�Y��[��B��S�3��4�q8.��n����Sh��j��}�S��#8��p:H����I��O5�0�P��<^b���'��_���S�̷1��?�Y��9�� i4�B�\����<�uH�9z�I�� ��!���;ԃi���D����a� h���fc~�fl�,vc���&R]��EO�$N����=N��kN6�aIpq�s�ky���v�ȗ��L7�Nc���h*͢���t��-�����%�e��ˀ\/����}flW�Yn��Z�<�W��yVa>�k���H3�1m��e2����^������w��9&�0��L�i4��zZI��U��):G��+1F���L1KԋF�Jl������G�/�r�|F�g�����e�T+�Wv(��rS�J��Pu��jP��~ V�gf�f�������5��da�SΫ�"�F��1���m�vb/�Ϊޫ���o�>�7q�q~� n�6�ʯ/�(�Fq}'�d�j^�մ��h��:G�$S+]�,c��� �j�^l���"Z�%^ S�x%R�dY&��yr�\%w����^�OFe�|SJ�R��P6*ە�1�-��eu�Z��� ����z��ۖac��E�6�:ǧ�^�[���;���I��>��l�O$�K�A� �($�۰_r��;b͕!���m�E4/���r���T�Je#���q)l���(�M,m?b��*�8��4 1TI�%1^i�L1T�����(���x��HftP~�aV:��:�� yo����p�.�grt���<�":K��/4@�����&���(M\�S�' w�l�������m�#��c65B��%�5������'�J��4��U�&����я�9bxnN������9X��K4���i����}�O�gr��I� =v��HA����� J�>eJ��� �� �Ƣ��6���i�-�l��Kw���˒�Z! ss4��Jt-J�>淖�~���JV�d�r�͛�P�мF�ꆰ7P��E<��.!7��Df�3���_DqF���G=9*#]/�iz��!3��Z����-�p���9yBz���HΎ��wc�<�=�F[l���Z$�5�%�DM ;�V� ��2�|�d������~ y��߳�k3d؛�X�`8��f��ݯuYO����"�4.e�[��e�{��>�6�K���ʪ#�:�kIK4��^�7��xm��f�sOOw��!ݫ��|�˘����%"!�. vJl�ίa�V�t����Fv�1l��"v�)�XǏ�欎�Iz�S���\۠?���xsԍFS��k��8��l�!������lK�tO�5<�s'��u��k8��~��~}� ����}Y�^VQ�Ӽ�@gm˪��}^���3�x|2Ctr"CƵܔ�-�K2�L���M]�;�+��J g`J�ӟ�r�����MkT�����0����^RXr�J�(�����x�Gtj�����������is�� � �#�Y�k�w\*���,�2�=.qUF�h�k�� �CQB\�'#���C�����#��z�Ϻ��^��_�.6�* �;3;3m��.k]h�NY�Ҏ�iK7tw�v�-mW�Jw��T[���I�Ԡ�����1�(Q��l ��A�O>��D�A�b��ߝN��/&��߹��sϝ;w��#+1l�)&R�l����*K�b�V��u=h��n�w��ܭ�y75����U�r s� s {$���3�=��4i��e2+|!����p�Dvγ,K�UK�K��PȻՃ�X/Sc�w�U�.�V߷~ú�<ዹ����N��� �>�s��W� a������DT$��vy�����M|�6��a{�"��g�B}&}3�#p/� h@-��@�PO�c�us��1���c�[v�j�M�D���T"��6i�\�#�:� B.�$�R�}2ߢ�"���� K�� �#���o���RJ>�aĻHy��M� { �l�CG�$?G�!�c�"^�&��/�Ul���R��m7�~P-��g�i-d>�Z�ap/��þ���X��?�Np%��)~F��%: �C���5Z�~5��|6`�H�iZ�Y�����J�K@��,��������ל���A/��c�s�ᱰv.K�B�J�cxvM>�w~��17�*��Ә����r��:�h0��r�e9�w��,wP�CqR |++��lU�s�-�� �8+1��E���࣋6����w���4|��P�����h�h�m�# L.�O _v�Q�����n��`�{�@V�D*K���s��F���k=���߷��� K�7e�����Z��7eF�0�) ���2e�~S� ��� �Lhd �'�kg��֚ؗ�Jۜ�?���M���b�?2�S#o_���۳whP����w���Z��z�H4���s�B�3(��3��#N�BȒ��J d5 2[i����y���h�A�� H~C��=y�S��xѠQ���h;�r7�� w ��t�F#�OQ�ЇH!�u@-�;���ɐ�kJp...
#2!���E�P,��ِ9���1��� ���y�?:)ȇ�� ?� � ����`��8J %Q �QeQa�ʣ*�*� ����j�j���!�1��)��9Z�%Z�5ڈ0�E;�GtD'tFtE7tG�D/�6M'��t1]�}��11�u!]XqމG��.&��@D'\rRu���u�.o���i�!�yh�Apm��i90C1 �1B,�H��h��X��xL�DLB8"0Y,�D�|L�4Da:f`&fa6�`.�9 0 ��Y�EX�%X�h�`�x�X�a9V +��D$aVc ~�Z��zl�Fl�f$c �b�cvbvc��l����\ו8�C8�#HA�x"��g��wq���@?ȉw��q�-�;�EM1N,�"F�w�j��mf��av�]f��c��}f�9`�Kv��m��抹j���I�s�<;�.� �"��.�#<�<�3����/���o��������������I5G�1s��2��s��3'�Is�\3�� s�_�G;��������~���O��$���_�������� �F���O���[�m�v���/��8����=�]��S�͈�a�� �@�q0$� �\�&�$��.��q��"�#� c�[ ��'���b��`��v�.�L�L��t�?��{�m�`<0��m�vc����e�?M�C#`(��%\��8�ti.��r���pW�+���e��]Q.����m|j�{���>����D��.�ax J������*9;�8�:�9�;�'�'� �8"��c⸨'�I� N���8�� &3���N�+)�H]��5����I�AV`��$[�4=�])t�Mz��_wo@omEDÑ�NJ����$� �Ǐ;��^�@�S�oj.vR}�\H)��b�E9ԛ��p`���Ns�P4U�=�����gʑ�yzm�^��K0�%�bu@�W����9ʤ�C/���<�����t�I�N��4������Sw���*��Qԙ�|�yTmU���(fQ6V�@�nD�։$��*�?�^�w�ϴ���y�\M�w��x0��TFs_Fp�X$p6��A�hXL9X�*��?��Zj� �'��^)w>\�!���,*��e���ӝ�{�V���]�lE�mrR3�<� �imB���5��T�S�c�ME�3~Y�V��|f�Z��_��['���D4��0 �K��x�p���#7��ڂu��t�$'� r�������B�uY]�����*��2���ϦOq�?�_n �Cj,��� ���p�3�@�����qQv�+�U��&-�W����N�����I5�������z x`�����5����!!<.�{����< \���F�O���4��d��... ���� b����`U�]�0�N�$�M�;u�/I�n������=�u�(��>�E���`��s �Oӊ���0V5���2�^Sը���q��WSx��e��V*�_�#m���k�߯���Z��g�v�#gp��0�'s�l�ck(E���2^m�Ǻ,�|pl9���%�;%t��-��.�f*�jP �B�@ �Ļ���p"��a����Q���!����ϧ�s��7���G�5E�Ϸ�����oփ;{�C��K�_��v���EA��hS�q� ߽�2�K��@o�D�7Ҁ`�\��x��[0����n__�m�� �֏��3�g0�����`��7�q��m�M���a��)[u�ݰa���Az�{���b�m�-^�/�fs w�l6�o�u����w_?����};ov~ϥ�_�wc�h/}��)ZOP�e��oqg��L�������p������$G<��穩g���27�gE��~ߨ+�\��|ӄJM ����� H��<� �3�)YO�"���� �?K�u��Q��F��>���>�+i�Q��Y��~�dB�Oo���ߣ1�-%�Y��FS�b�M��\`:�^{-�d�Eh���Ё��ϯ��f��<�ӏ�0�P1�ހF��XՔ"�]|}m��-b��[x�G�'q ĭ��L��Tj�)\��]_j�S���/O�B/2G�e�9c�qӟ�km��j>�[��%��4�GX_�ah��n}�S)qh���wp_��ޡC�����،t�Q���@%��S��yK�"+�vA��l�Y���E�.����j�,���l����b��T� h1݉��+�[-��Dh�|j��ڃ�@���,َ?�y�R�w������3s�����g���oڹ8�P������GA�*Է�k}�h��)@�y�fI%��dz��6tV./ó�D�L+7U��F�VeNS/�: Ϟ����l�&�I���J��r��u����%�YO��s+o*4s*W����x�@H!�g'���zw�)��3��l@n��ϣ��SťxWe.R�9LYМi�Xگ?���Б����(ƾA�U/�������]m� �;�+�}f�E�u�Z�͙����b��U| ��ogQϐLz��m��k�y���B �.���sGr���;�\+��P����� �8��+�Yw� ���[�A�f����h�]I9!%�[M��V)��4v��4�v�K@�>h�@n(ZVr� v��[vs��[~�-������i�z����<+�u\��� ߜ�t;4 ��qg����V^���5�V� r6�Zz0r�$ꨏ�6�#^��_(>���M_|G�c��6g(�V�E�#���+ s�@�r˾��L�� ڢ)�m�}���CZs�����������e��X�����Z���<ޅ4�Dc=&� ���At����A�9w�} ��ľ���� ��L��\im�v�Gݼ�>�eς���/��s��GZ��1k�!�|��,�m��Ҽ8?=�(l�nA ���-\� 0?��j8 �� �8��<�=����6G����⩫��sy �O�m�����'�.p�b���܈���Q���i�eV8��M����T�*���u���M+�_p�k��:�i����C��W���x�/�eUu����s�������sW"... H)G�� gq����˲'yD�%�C��A0 ~�9 V�Y�r�M����L^� ?��$;��ŭ��=#�@�ۆ �1<(Ϥpv�����n�� ����aoE�XoKu9{�Ġ\�� ��GM�0�� �~/~7�7 endstream endobj 8 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 7/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 9 0 obj <>stream H��Wmo�6��_q�k��z���[�t�e(V���b)���9I���e;�`@������y�����ٻm��-�ys����Ų���l����y��y�<+��Y�&9dye��"+�i�[���龴5�}�˪��ٜ�>�w�M٭� �}{~y'g�y �'q�������?�I�8��V��4�����z�g�E&uGL�0�>K�L`�ů& \���=��0�dGc��p= �H�S?!�������4��d. ~@�I�^=��肅I#�<�J���1��[��.����!� њ�\�;y�6W���;�)�1��J�,$E�� �)�%�R���` �@�VƯ'��%���"��]p��/4�����AJ���=|`�@�J���.zG����,���6��nד2y���=���B�p?���!�d�7]{p�Y�i ��&I���0S�?7M�5`��X>�9�v7cٗ��s��Gr����K��CB0R�$��c�����q�1"R\�A8%�=��)�>);��*�B� ���Ҽ���dS��F����H�R�)&����������l�y��>���O�1+�zX�8h�-D�6`��m"O�����blX�xK�� ��� ��O��s��wZ�?�<ɚ�3�0�f@-��n2n�W�wp#�P�7%ڥTʅ�B3п�h�(��qQ&��%�����D�D��?�L9��m���+���}l�{:����}t�#M�M�ss��]�-��� �`K�x\�=�!Hnx��5��U;�9��j�Q�t�{��1�����ott:��& �������u�1�Y\6;�{5>�������4��>���_ҵy w ��Wx+TZ�j���/�~Eײ�k�Nƫ�>m6>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 8/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 11 0 obj <>stream H��W�n�H}�W��BX�x�<���q6��6�'gڢn�C29��v]�Y��V����fu���S�nVWo��a�����7M���M��VU�������Rwi�i��,L�8JU�f~��*K2?O��,���7��F]�s���Q]����J��R�����[uq�Z-T�Vۋ��X�����U�VO*��E�揮2�G�������?^�j��~�f��<�ڼ���h�R5[�ý��zg~c5k�y�P���.��5����qͿ� �ߏ^��j�"�d@�m�̳�q!T����pk<����UBz���^ �f1��x���=�DIC=膞�k����W&���o!NG�ȼ4!��~J��S��$���7��-��o0ucJݜ2wy4)k�5��*ɱJ`L��YD�s�KX�Zĺ,_"4K4S��ʌ�!�x� ���YI�#���(I��x���.�n� �"��\�Y��2.�긹��B��� ���(��b5F�<k�7�A�m<����9B�����Z���� B�9�c����[Q��~���2kBZ3w�:w�f�Jo#!����`5��G^��5/��ݬ���y$�K�`�y>7�����E&{� ��ߪ�U�%v9�OY��.�V��'&0�q�� ����A.#@��y�/#���؇����_麦+����|�C.l(:pI�<%�iϥ{���H�{�K�x����� �qߊ �wU�M5�rw�� g��:> �T�=�:��D�.��[���[5&W��5&jCQQ�����t�$@���0��v���^h��8�B�(;kH� P�j�!��c���X��g7�_�I2�����{`������#�%���(�Ʉ�À�g��vP]�.��9Fl7����-"�;EE�7mW�\r�i�p��p�v4� �Q�d��%�&�G�U�r��)�$9�ԑ�1�D���k^�L��S\���+��... �qc��]C�7%�Q Yge�����T��R��I��Ȧ����g o'��7�oM�ϳ�D ��~+��# h�OA�Nc7��-��xG�1߈�jA��i�K �VR�u��T���[�I��K >𬓮�N���e>�Ba�ʓ�>����/�p��(��k8�����N?<�N�[���#���y� �U�8�G��t�k���<��Ėm�� ���������"�������Gy���m�w�>�����&�}�S�i�Am�@��`$YbBS�M9��w��.-��ݝ˙ٙ3g �N9DX���i�(Ӟ��b�Ó�9���&�b#N� z���U��a��6rO+#��������k�{��js�z/�G�|~.��<4�AL<<��+n�2)�:4�g�N�j�� ������+2��A`$��p��\�/�Z��^W��Jg�������u�".��Z��qqu��Ã�cquu��|�3�h��E��8]�,���������f����qX��ۇjW�U_C1���.�J.�~Vp<�,H�{���?r��KS :�y�^ܳ{�&^��M ��PB�"#bZ�2�UzXe6F��`�r�X��#�k�lh�o��qpc��Bdc�r&'���%��Ȉ��E�/��X�ڭ�k~]�oe��]B��3�6J,q�9I���6@nk�� =�|U����K��m�"��(�#���Mo��Y$��;U�Q?�X jd��L�U�:��Е��>��\�-�|���h^ڌ���O��K��g7�c}-��vdt�� n�� D��wl��%ԛ�z�@2?��c�H��-�,T����t]Rg.^y�A��pMk�M9c����r���e��V=����2��|�SE�~�0T ך ��C?�����φ��b������,�uGi^����i+���@��G)�i��$���F��}$L�@���,Bkp~��ך�-<4�(_֘U4�ĩ�;���+j��ɇ���˸�;�P ������n�,�p��PZ�3�� ��6"��p,�\��e��ι� �$�����)QiS�$���%�f�y,3'4Ma:�V;��R�_#�xN��� @Q e��%�}�V�d���J��n������fT�����&2��8���夆 3�6���e��[0���|@B��48X�ACCr�B�Z��=3/g��%���'�y �U�i�p��_�3#94Vq����=�$�W3sm�EK�֚�|�7� Y �q�{��W��J=��<��:�^�f*�c�Ȃ�5���Zý=�����IDA�0��Ə%O�z�H���it�˻̦�|C"��ܢ�����Mx�o�bܷk�V<�u��-�`�gi�À����(�Q ���M�~Y�SV .��&{5x ��svӏ�ޯb��I��j��6��WJN����4�˻��M�T�='��.�҈� ~E�XP��Ц�o{��R���T�^�$I���ɷ7i(���- ��υ�L�+�7vaDMZⱇ�h��W�݄�'`�H��vt[̞굒��W��<�v�I^FKo?�d�sL�����uD)@8B0�e�C��3�&�n���8���<��i(MQh... U)�� ���>Y�u �JG�����1e��q�9�U�����>�w�X6����A��qQ�u����' i?�)����nh6�Gy��W۽3:�{�� ݊騼�R���쫯]���>�e��q�M�?��Vu��'2������t<���r{�d�V�/ߪsz�4롾_��/of����8�a�!�� ��q��� R�_P�� �$��+wb�ؗ��f��Ӻ̠����n`�ݝ��Ƭ��0��(��i� ?�C��$�� N�͆�\ �� ����A�G,�v9ޢ�vD7?��7��g_���Mb���ߟ�b�~@�P����9�dьO�� p�`(�c{��S2NH5?q�k��s���?v���@AK%�\3�Ӟ��Jo�r���▇ϲ���6�ea͟�%vt[���� a�BK���oq&O ,��SO�_J*֪�S\���X ) En�t2�����2���P���sWs���1�������qt�'���W��;�uf���v:� '��vi�����^�O\y(��]��RMv�;Dķ X�>stream h�26U0P�6�0RA & : �1 o endstream endobj 16 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 13/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 17...
./r\e��Q��m�_�2�k.�G|,�s��x��,H-�,�4~�$�#3�����ȭK�� �f���Te]���R����iU�֬��4�6y 2K�R����p �鴞V��?΄�b<&�� �L��zZ�a&$[� �K���e�XX�%��-��A#� eQ���V������И1fAX��u��u9I~*��-������^�F�Y�}m���~�3�����{dD#˭��%��]�gk�yZۏ� �C ����'�:S��'?*"5��r{y�@E[���|��j$,���M��3���Eq Qw� ��ǂ��j� ��7@����Uj�#!�u ��Ɉ��S{@>��5�]�0��Z��!�x�!�"��XDD��cV0E�Zȷ˚�h ��-2�L�d���|F���Y�X�}�ΰ]ϴ[O��p��Wۙ�\ģ�W�Y��G�a�~ ����=����?����}nb�.Z.��~�=�^��/t�mJ�裦��w��/�2�` E�alܱG��HDS ������8#!i{����B6���B�= �9\&�ϊ�>Ts�RM�?�̵�q�`�L#���x��n�� P��`� &�9qɿ 2B$;zm���8D�����Ax���f����R�Y;ԗ��#T{��d��浜5�_ਈ���G;��0��c�npͽSQ���]�o�<3� kh�k @S�w�hd�L�t���|fWB6 XG `D��N��u�%�udJ�-��?b�Lp>����E)���'SmԯO5�@w�pblz:Sj�Sg�6�p�Ūh��:L\���ZU� #�y�<�N}؈��F̲�e�f3s��Z�3$i�YW�;��b��MY#Si Dz��К����Ցx��F���T1���#@L@��������~�C@7�<�������?1��P����z�F;����Ek �si���h��i����.ڡ��@��,��*뼲 [��`� ��gаϏ[��Μe�����r=�Lp^���� ��A#�Ip�\�ktm�bx2@[t4.�t�"ay��,��E��6b�d�v�Fe�೯� �W�[W���f�Wmc# ��N˖�O�q�Hې4l@�%����2��... m�SU��5R�Ϻ�x-�^^}?�`��8H����TPi~�E� ��o�[��VV��C������|ހ�d�����Ek`���4��z��0�&��<.}�~Kׂ|���#�n�}�*"�jLc�i��srb��O�M{wP��Wf�[ ��o�QXn���0 J��x)2ģ�B6����To%.���@�`��? Ɔ�)n��@# `˯�M\&&{0s����d�xd��;�� �$W���xͩ�`.�b��N(���I�Ӽ��n���xt� ��]ӹ[���}������[x�l��`pA���i~��J��'|s�V�3�t4�1:U���w�j�N�n?��q�ӻ�Y�g~��̧G�.i z��a��a��ƈx,���,�����#�E�Qp��q�F���Kx�[t�Fr6���}Id$�>d�R:��xx�*�ǯ���Xp��dBgp~ ��Da���5�@�y��m�<�ўu���)@i&�u��0Э!���"w����m�D���VYƼ��Y)�9W���ҩ��"�^N�g�p�n�s�7o����7���N2�]���]��� ���V(�p��&�� �VT���ṕ�L��5�� q=X�:�B_�1�+.M@�P�碝���������e���N���U�gC�\�: }٠J��y-��:g6�I�{ z��@x9��yh��x� VaBXVVq��sK�n���H��<��%���r�^^�{9D`�F`Js� P��YFX mQb .e�[��"aqc�����}��^=i�s(:���2�mA�T����6���-�w���_�K� endstream endobj 21 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 18/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 22 0 obj <>stream H��W�r�F}�W̓��"���]�JE�;�(�ڬ�����D�%�%����/sDR�7�*�����>�ϜΎ�'��溞o�O?MO6�z�Z.��t֭�_�����2O�ʳB:�i��,/d�iQd�,�\���۫ͷ�RL�.���^Lg����i�z�t����ӳ��h:��B���Q,�n�b�w��= ��81����5��fwG��Q&�-�Xfb�M�ె����S.Fs~����s�O�h��m,F �ǁ���/ф����/�T�b4c�l@�c���{pA�QǞ<�I�5g�p��zm,�D�r�vн���h�ӎz�5����;�1�1�Ps��H�B�i���f��(����-�H�B`W����Y�у�և夠ؽ�ح�7��6��u��R '\��W�L�_-:%���i,S�?I*�31QPm���`��(��4��xJf ������ ��=�}�m6ݝ+n]�~�T$�X7Ir��... ��x���ot�5�XU���� ?�%.7�:�2��[���Ӊ�d0]S��k�bA�c)�-��7��= �zmIRy�2�]�=_YMeܠ �ښ�uW����&ؖ�F�0�i�h�����b���H�}�'�����mHj ֝�A�����(}U�DB�J������ ��?}Do�E�oԘ�����m�yhy���F��!���-}����6��� ��g� n�X+��o�Hk��;:����B�W�������u�R�0�N��;� ��n!&����/ ,|�5K��E�P��j3>�� ~v@�PZI����j���hF�F=���iG OU��`;=�P�v"�B�#i�"u���x?Ǧ�pv�l t��`�X���v���{D��gzݝ?Z�� � |�ҷ�tu�π�����q��W��XЦ�+�)6Ds�YV4���� ���45�$��&*� ��B�&>*S�er��R���x%|�\��^��ip]t���W�I�R�C��:,�R�":�@fe*3�Ǒx�$B�"�s�CJ���D�!5�4U"�Ŧ����8�S��PeQ�!�8:ݝG-�c�Bo�d�rX��9)�^� giߒGa-���C��f���^Qo��}8�v0�O�zp�J��tޞ���UO)�hy=T�p���'�j�:�>:�܊��!��v|Cݐf�w�4^�*�=�e��& ̉x�ⅼu�K�ȗ; 2(}LKǤLV�^��Gk������V�deB�ދ�;?O\;�d[ wl�4�l��N��[����e���;#@��*FE����۵ ':��, �S/��c�;"��=W^[�����?E:a@�v QC)_���v�DH���n�&��~<$�q1��M�4�tC�-��?%��JhC��\Kͦ?�m 顖pI4���i�y�bf�"��[����J�v������3@S��4-�qD��=�@%���r��;�!��B�2/�C��!c˻ �D�����{ e���v��/߾�U)߫��U���i�P�� �����02��}���%��5O����r���q����v����C���^�@��7>pdO�̖����:�e$#ZI�R<`���� N��n��{yi�� ���3�Y�>~ʾ'|�t�����0!�~#>�^|�T�h�f.d�5`�KW/T\�Wie1��\g�O��w+d�13c\Ve�k� �$�J�,��t��-bԩI���c|�r7)J̡�5Z�eVU�����gIVHeΦ3��S�{��Rz���I�Q���X0q�cp�l�nlt��Ak|�p� �Q���I᎑A��/���xY��|x��Be��S��3ə9���;^"<~S�&���[����O ��s{T��鿲rG: �... ^�Y 3�Y��tbuA�/t[i\h����*�76��e�˯���'W�ΐsF̜�Lҋw���1�`����,���Spv k*���&�M�9��(\~�D{�O�� /�j<5A��SZ�Ϳr��,G|��I�䈭^.��ꉎ��`0v_�ʤ��3�GM_Y�_����q�7ӄ��dZ��pyR��ڤ�ǫ�4��E^Ď� �}���Z6�t �*�w �,-L�.-;��Z��@O��ikgľ�!��rb�@ǧ��)+_Ձ!�X��@u�A ��V��*BF�@68� �@���\Է?a�3���@d%��S�6�C�{�$m�ryRgD���!�%ս8CzCإf���$x8� �ݫ�I��#��J"������������=2�� �s����Wj���E��-%*eeis����d-�^�"�u̮����5�Ƕ{&��[���8O�_z�ƨ���b�k�ũr9�'��q��T����T�(I�S$�"�.U�ٴ* ��tl\�З_�`}D/��0���)y+�0M 12D��K�)��M$̭)z(|���a�m�t���R-~ E�'�� �`���q� S�Q�coz�ц��K+��i�k��G0�=��'��� ��T�3n�"�t�X��+�Z�=j�vA��4���=�� MGӟz���L�̙�GA�k9P�7�G^_Q`NX p�rZD��䌙���!�#�/����9]&)��*���d19�M θ�8��8�*|�qW�+LJP��o�b�r+��E��z�.L�.��ZѮ̋/����wOt�Q�v�L$")R,-@{�Q�y �*S~�P��|9��/��8���,��~��~z� g}�<��t��Jy�ku��i�b%zjSĩ='-�U�0�6eu����}#��J��Im@ۛ�mW ��ijmF��+�n�hX[W�E??�`�ج1@غ0�d�� ������* endstream endobj 23 0 obj <>stream h�,�1 EA+��@�V�x�-���VT�L��oL �%O<��O�xo�n� endstream... =��a����f��얻��zq��\/�lww�Z����w���6�����o��n��~[��y��-~��}ܮ?�-e�����<��|h��ֿ �jq�??�<}�}}�^]~^��`��ǝ�U2�z��Xmw�|���f{�0~>��Ӂ�b�o7*���ֿ��#���U��Z?�����l���?<�fù�?W��:�9���r��T�F�-�-�-�-�-T[����/ �3�3�3�A�K�O�O�o��� ��`���`����DJ����\D���u��Ƈ��y�����)����gg_��ۿ�;��o�������[���Ɛ_�������\�+IKA<�4�X�"Jeab"�� �0݃H9P����Sķ�wk���(~/P���Gs�Д�Vܞ�maA�"D� 5��1�.Ò�+"N¬5�֖���#���ZN��4wc-@挤)T��d9�S��zOF r0�y��HpQ��k��2�eG�&��2�=���4���9�q�C-��% i�|�s 9��B ��@��ϖ=[��8�3:I'�� p��]L�W��������Zf�:8n��-LtB���G�܄�M�S!�7�� wl�Ľ�5�g����q��������ۯ� �!�J B�&(�Z{ s�4A�-��N|�!8$8g�t�Q�����B;�<��R8ٺ~f�;�CRσ�X/|#�^�g^�]*GιrˌΈ����g�'�cd~F�ed~�Re�a��α$�< ��|��3ܝ��p�Fb�'F ���)��y: �2�>Sc+>o}Cn7M3@��(��$4Q��A�1[�����&a�0�1N�� z�����c�#��X����/��Ӧq;��Ӧq�xk�4ݍ�F_� tT瑈��h�|��_,�@��?���H_����1$} �x�a��:u�y+��P|ʏP/˱j�(TjP�C���R �e�pj��C���I��C���I�1����F7�j�!���F�(�'FV}<����s~Q�If�L�+$\8RVU �$i2�W$>�J�3ݽֹs�����"�o�G<=]Y3湹�S�C��.�U��� �����v����;f����MDk�wU#�Y��x#�G�ڞ�}��vEiw,�%`~�"n�m���I>stream hޔWAod5 �+9�&�'�V+��b�-�Fs(U�J�C�����y�����;�8�_�ώ�!�!����!(4���$�9Cb\2���S�,��y� l~3��T�e �$��1e �f �r����4��\�F��A���Oc(���B1{�Z�^%T��j2�jE���u�|Ikh��a������B/ز�Q�6�2D*���h*�A4c ��, l�:��*�~U�%cP�EZ����@n� r9�̀�Xm����{àa����͕�E��9c�`...
�4MX[�f��� iB�F�;Z�i 6�� ���p5�w�� ����nx����!����˻�~��?�'fJ�ߡ�G���}x����i�{�xn��L�P���q����8�<���s&��4!��4K5qY3n&G�h�$+Y����`n����s�9�>�ќ� N�C;M�����y�g�>��s��� v��$��sPC��v�u�9͚l�k63��}63�+>��s�}�Vs����̠n�9��K��L>��l�k63X6�lf���\��5tY�jn68i6#X��l&���\��uv��5��� `�h�=���`hV�n��6�Vv��I�����h3�u��֍n���l�'�f���l�-{,~�X��=[��>�&�V������8wų���lp�?���v�� ���Qs�]�Vs���#����4����Y���e���3��K�ׂ~�?z��tJ���k�z͒ �R7��;<;=Pj���>쎼�x8<%���[Wв���gJ1������C��o#G�e�..1�%��4Gח��>w�(�d����*Y�1џ��7d�N֧"��l�اB�D&}����L��u����Y���"Y�������./��ޗp��7�������)Y#>�����������y�������p������a��t� ��������� 0=�� endstream endobj 27 0 obj <>stream hޔWMo7�+<��z�1�p�@�ݴH`�5�=>8�M�Q���͊�MEtOKif�{����.%q�]"�p .��kt�*�Ʌ�q%c�5��QA�E)��4%\��@#q��_��P�rpT����99��5N.W���Jn.�d�g�8�:Ve�₺�] ���jB]��Vԕ�$��p�����R\�JX����yH-��rBo���tTVF��%F�Q��'!)1g,��9)5������Ȥ��&���� ��� ��RrQv���dV� d-rMh��*�Y>stream h��Xks�D�+��~о��h�R`J�4e t:E�Ģ��#�d̯笜����~(��ZK�8���ޕV�p�U ��� �"��U)%��Hep�D9�+�]5�H��#��~���q �)�3����F� 1��$x�1�! ���!Bq,i,�G�ṳG��G��/�� ��-p��X\�<��ȣ�X ��p�X�Z"GԘK�... Articles may include CRediT roles and/or a free text Author Contributions statement to describe the activities of each person who contributed to the article. CRediT roles and Author Contributions statement are optional components that should be tagged if available for an article. CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) is a high-level taxonomy of 14 roles that can be used to describe the activities of each person in producing a scholarly output. Any individual contributor (an author) may have zero or more CRediT roles assigned. Multiple contributors may share the same CRediT roles, and may optionally indicate degree of contribution.
If CRediT information is provided for an article (typically transmitted in article metadata), the CRediT roles for each author should be tagged using the <role> element within <contrib> as part of the article metadata. CRediT roles should be displayed in typeset PDFs as a backmatter section titled “Author Contributions” and formatted according to the Interact template guide; although note that CRediT roles should not be duplicated within the... Author Contributions Statement is a section of free text that acknowledges the specific contributions of each person. Because it is free text, an author contributions statement can contain detailed information that is not possible to convey using the CRediT taxonomy, and may contain some CRediT roles or adaptations of CRediT roles. When an author contributions statement is provided it should be placed in the back of an article (within <back>) either as its own section tagged using a <sec> element with attribute @sec-type="author-contributions" or as... Ideally, CRediT information should not be duplicated within an article because any inconsistencies may require input from the authors to resolve.
For articles in production, if authors have provided CRediT roles this information will typically be included in the article metadata transmittal from CATS. The CRediT roles should be tagged using <role> elements within article metadata, and displayed in the PDF using the formatting described in the Interact template guide without duplicating CRediT information between article metadata and... A research project that leads to a published article may involve many people who take on different roles to make that article successful. From designing the study, collecting the data, and writing the manuscript, how do you fairly give credit to everyone who was involved? The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) provides criteria for determining who qualifies to be an author, as well as guidance for acknowledging the work of others who contributed but don’t qualify for... However, the ICMJE doesn’t provide a standardized way to do this, leading to inconsistencies in how authors describe the contributions from non-authors.
Even for those who do qualify for authorship, but who aren’t listed as the first or last author, the contributions of middle authors may not be obvious or recognized. The Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT), first developed in 2014 and now an ANSI/NISO standard, provides a structured way to formally and transparently recognize the work of all authors and non-authors on a paper. CRediT is made up of 14 roles that describe how someone contributed to a publication. A few examples of these roles include Data Curation, Funding Acquisition, Supervision, Visualization, and Writing – Review & Editing. How does this work in practice? Publishers can adopt CRediT by providing an opportunity for the submitting author to list the contributions during the manuscript submission process.
The American Chemical Society, SAGE, and Elsevier are just a few examples of publishers that have either implemented CRediT or are piloting it. If the journal you’re submitting to doesn’t ask you about CRediT, you can still use the CRediT terminology in your manuscript. Have a discussion with your co-authors about using CRediT in your paper before submitting to make sure that everyone agrees. You’ll also find CRediT included in ORCID and publishing systems such as Crossref, which will help provide a mechanism for keeping track and storing information on CRediT and making these contributor roles even more... Looking forward, expect to see a push to apply CRediT to more types of research outputs to provide even greater transparency in support of open science principles.
People Also Search
- Clarification around Contribuitor Roles (specification of each role)
- CRediT Contributor Roles - All 14 Research Roles Defined | CASRAI
- CRediT role descriptors
- PDF Contributor Roles in Multiple Author Submissions
- Endorsement of the Contributor Roles Taxonomy for the clarification of ...
- LibGuides: Authorship and Contributorship: CRediT Taxonomy
- PDF 1. Contributor Roles Taxonomy1 - nmt.edu
- Author Contributions and CRediT | JATS Guide
- Transparent Authorship: Giving CRediT Using the Contributor Roles ...
- 14 CRediT Contributor Roles Explained | Complete Taxonomy Guide
I Am Writing Because I Need Clarification On Contributor Roles,
I am writing because I need clarification on contributor roles, as I couldn’t find satisfactory answers in the existing documentation. I would like to know the specific definitions for each of the following “contributor” roles. Is there a specific page or guideline that details these functions?: For example, when crediting the peer reviewers who conducted the peer review and who are also editors o...
How Should I Distinguish Between Them? Also, If A Group
How should I distinguish between them? Also, if a group of authors each performed a specific function, how do I distribute the “first-author” and “additional-author” roles? The CRediT taxonomy provides a standardized vocabulary for describing research contributions. Unlike traditional authorship lists that only show names, CRediT makes explicit what each person contributed to the research. Each of...
This Flexibility Accurately Represents How Modern Collaborative Research Actually Works.
This flexibility accurately represents how modern collaborative research actually works. Click on any role below to learn more about its definition, examples, and implementation guidance: Ideas; formulation or evolution of overarching research goals and aims. Management activities to annotate, scrub data, and maintain research data for initial and later use. These are the 14 roles included in the ...
While CRediT Is Being Used By Publishers To Capture Information
While CRediT is being used by publishers to capture information about the specific contributions of its authors, is is not designed to determine authorship; publishers adhere to strict guidelines around what qualifies as authorship. The CRediT roles can also be used to describe the contributions of individuals in contexts not related to article authorship. Conceptualization – Ideas, formulation or...
Department Of Periodontology, Seoul National University School Of Dentistry, 101
Department of Periodontology, Seoul National University School of Dentistry, 101 Daehak-ro, Jongno-gu, Seoul 03080, Korea. periopf@snu.ac.kr, Tel: +82-2-2072-2642, Fax: +82-2-744-1349 Received 2017 Feb 7; Accepted 2017 Feb 7; Issue date 2017 Feb. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licens...