The Story Of The Constitutional Convention As James Madison Wanted It

Americans seeking to understand how the founders developed our Constitutional framework of government have faced a problem deliberately created by the founders, who agreed on a rule of strict secrecy during their deliberations at... Still, several delegates, conscious of the historical significance of the convention—and concerned about how its outcome would be interpreted—did keep private notes during the proceedings. James Madison set out to make as complete a record as possible, taking notes during each day’s debates and converting these each night into dialogues capturing the main points discussed that day. He held onto these notes until his retirement when he revised them for publication after his death. After this version was published by Henry Gilpin in 1840, 19th-century readers frequently consulted it as they debated the meaning of the Constitution. Yet, due to the work of later editors, 20th and 21st-century readers have been distanced from the account Madison completed in retirement.

Professor Gordon Lloyd, a Senior Fellow at Ashbrook and Dockson Professor Emeritus at Pepperdine University, decided to restore the story of the convention as Madison wanted it to be told. Lloyd’s Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787, by James Madison, a Member, was published by Ashbrook press in 2014. It is now available at our online bookstore. We asked Lloyd to explain why he restored this version of the Debates. 1. In your introduction to the volume, you say, “Madison wasn’t a court-appointed stenographer.” His record of the debates does not capture every word spoken.

It’s based on his daily diary of events, but it also reflects Madison’s mature thinking about what happened in 1787. Why did Madison return to his earlier account and revise it? Madison was responding to an urgent public interest in what happened behind the closed doors of the convention. The Framers were dying, but the story had not yet been properly told. Madison wanted to tell the story, while choosing the time of its release. Because of a joint resolution of Congress calling for the records of the convention to be gathered and published, Madison had been asked in 1818 by John Quincy Adams, then Secretary of State, to...

Madison had refused. He said that he did not want them to be used in public debates then ongoing over the powers of the judiciary and whether and how to limit slavery. He told Adams he did not want his account published until after his death. Adams continued collecting all the information about the convention he could. He acquired the “journal” of the convention—a record kept by William Jackson, who was tasked to keep minutes of those who attended and of votes taken. Adams also acquired the notes of New York delegate Robert Yates and South Carolina delegate Charles Pinckney.

He compiled and published these records as the Journal, Acts, and Proceedings of the Convention . . . which Formed the Constitution of the United States in 1819. (Later, in the mid-19th century, historian Jonathan Elliott combined these records, along with various letters commenting on the convention and the records of debates in several state ratifying conventions, and published them in a... He used Jackson’s journal to check his own record of the dates and results of votes taken at the convention.

Yates’ notes were incomplete since Yates left the convention in early July. Pinckney’s account appalled Madison. It altered the chronology of decisions, moving discussions that took place after a first draft of the Constitution was written to the discussions of June and early July. Madison wanted to give posterity a truer account. An essay documenting Madison as intellectual leader and keeper of the memory of the gathering that created the United States Constitution in the summer of 1787. In the 1820s and 1830s James Madison struggled to draft a "Preamble" and "Sketch never finished nor applied" for a preface to his planned publication of his "Notes of Debates in the Federal Convention...

Constitution. Now that document's fiftieth anniversary was approaching as fast as Madison's life was slipping away. As far back as the 1790s, Madison had planned to publish his journal of notes from the convention and had begun to "correct" it accordingly. Later he even had his wife's brother, John C. Payne, recopy his journal and incorporate many of his emendations and corrections into the text. Yet Madison continually postponed the publication of his journal out of fear that his political enemies would use it against him and that its incompleteness and errors would distort a strict-constructionist approach to the...

To thwart such misrepresentation, he spent time throughout several decades improving his journal until there were many emendations, deletions, interlineations, and insertions in the text. As the fiftieth anniversary approached, some people had begun to call Madison the Father of the Constitution. However, he feared that the publication of his journal would lead his enemies to mock him and that he would be drawn into controversy, just as his friend Thomas Jefferson had become immersed in... Nevertheless, Madison reflected back on the road to the Constitution during dull winter days at Montpelier. His work on George Mason's draft of the Virginia Declaration of Rights was the first step towards independence and the Constitution. He still had his amended copy of the Virginia Declaration of Rights (June 8, 1776) in his papers.

He could see his major contribution, the replacing of the phrase "all men should enjoy the fullest toleration in the exercise of religion" with "all men are equally entitled to the full and free... —William Pierce, delegate to the Constitutional Convention from Georgia, 17871 James Madison was born on March 16, 1751, at Port Conway, King George County, Virginia. He was the son of James Madison Sr. and Nelly Conway Madison. On September 15, 1794, at the age of 43, he married Dolley Payne Todd; they had no children.

Madison died on June 28, 1836, at his Virginia home, Montpelier, where he is buried. He was the last surviving delegate of the 1787 Federal Convention. Madison studied under private tutors and then attended the College of New Jersey (now Princeton University), graduating in 1771. Republican (with Jefferson, co-founded the Republican Party in 1792) 1774: Committee of Safety for Orange County, Virginia James Madison, known as the "Father of the Constitution," was instrumental in shaping and advocating for the U.S.

Constitution. His vision, intellect, and political acumen helped establish a government that balances liberty and order, creating a framework that has endured to what we know it as today. Madison’s role at the Constitutional Convention of 1787 was unparalleled. Before the delegates even gathered in Philadelphia, he arrived prepared with a clear plan for reform which he called the Virginia Plan. Drawing from his extensive knowledge of history, political theory, and government systems, Madison’s plan became the foundation for the Constitution’s framework. This blueprint outlined a strong central government with three branches—legislative, executive, and judicial—and introduced the principles of checks and balances, as well as a bicameral legislature.

The plan’s emphasis on proportional representation in at least one house sparked critical debates that shaped the final document. Madison’s contributions went beyond structure; he infused the Constitution with principles designed to address the realities of human nature. He understood that human imperfection necessitated safeguards to prevent tyranny. In Federalist No. 51, he famously wrote, “If men were angels, no government would be necessary.” This pragmatic view informed his advocacy for federalism and separation of powers, ensuring no single entity or branch could dominate. Madison believed that ambition would counteract ambition, creating a system that protected liberty through institutional balance.

However, Madison’s work was far from over once the Convention ended. He became one of the Constitution’s fiercest advocates, working to persuade skeptics during the ratification process. Alongside Alexander Hamilton and John Jay, Madison co-authored The Federalist Papers, a series of essays explaining and defending the Constitution. His most notable contributions include Federalist No. 10 and Federalist No. 51.

In Federalist No. 10, Madison argued that a large republic would better manage factions by preventing any single group from dominating, while Federalist No. 51 outlined the necessity of checks and balances to preserve liberty and prevent tyranny. These essays not only shaped public opinion but have also become cornerstones of American political thought. Although Madison initially believed the Constitution sufficiently protected individual liberties, he recognized the need to address Anti-Federalist concerns. As a member of the First Congress, he drafted the Bill of Rights, ensuring protections for fundamental freedoms such as speech, religion, and the press.

This achievement helped secure public trust and solidify the Constitution’s acceptance. Use this Narrative with the Constitutional Convention Lesson and after students have done The Articles of Confederation, 1781 Primary Source activity. The 1787 Constitutional Convention traces its origins to early September 1786, when Virginia congressman James Madison and eleven other delegates interested in increasing the powers of the national government met at a tavern in... Although attended by representatives of only five states – New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Virginia – the Annapolis Convention issued a report, written by Alexander Hamilton, citing “important defects in the system... Members proposed a convention in Philadelphia the following May to discuss possible improvements to the Articles. In February, Congress endorsed the idea.

Members of Congress and others were increasingly concerned that the Articles of Confederation was inadequate. The Articles placed strict limits on the power of the national government, which had a unicameral legislature of equally represented states, no independent executive, no national judiciary, no power to tax or regulate interstate... Congress needed supermajorities to pass certain laws and unanimity to pass amendments. During the Confederation period in the 1780s, states ignored congressional requisitions for taxes, passed tariffs on each other, nearly went to war over trade and territorial disputes, and routinely overlooked the provisions of the... Members of the Virginia delegation, including Washington and Madison, arrived in Philadelphia early. Believing the states were too powerful compared to the central government, they met with the Pennsylvania delegation and drafted a plan of government, largely of Madison’s design.

This Virginia Plan was guided by the goal of creating a much stronger national government to govern the country more effectively. On Friday, May 25, 1787, the delegates assembled in the Pennsylvania State House. All agreed the Articles of Confederation had numerous weaknesses that needed to be addressed, but they disagreed strongly on the appropriate solutions. First, the convention unanimously selected Washington to preside as president, and his prestige legitimized the gathering in the minds of many. The delegates then decided to allow each state delegation one vote and to conduct the proceedings in secret to allow greater candor in free and open debate. As the weakness and wants of man naturally lead to an association of individuals, under a Common Authority, whereby each may have the protection of the whole against danger from without, and enjoy in...

People Also Search

• The Story of the Constitutional Convention: as James Madison Wanted It ...
• James Madison and the Federal Constitutional Convention of 1787
• James Madison: Father of the Constitution - The Heritage Foundation
• James Madison: The Father of the Constitution - Constitutional Coalition
• The Constitutional Convention (LLPH) - Bill of Rights Institute
• James Madison: Origin of the Constitutional Convention, Decemb
• James Madison and the Constitution | Gilder Lehrman Institute of ...
• James Madison's Role in the Constitutional Convention: Key Insights
• James Madison | Constitution Center
• 1787: Madison's Notes of Debates in the Federal Convention